A common and devastatingly effective strategy deployed by big food and drug companies to peddle their products is the idea that if you just create enough confusion with consumers we’ll stick to status quo and / or consuming their products.
I’ve fallen for it many times.
Though I thankfully never saw the appeal of cigarettes (I bring this up as the tobacco industry is most infamous for championing confusion), I absolutely subscribed to the “tofu gives you flabby hips and thighs” myth. I was just confused enough about the potential “estrogen mimicking effects of soy” and certainly more than incentivized enough at the prospect of not growing my already flabby thighs that I avoided soy for the majority of my vego years.
I also ditched almost all fruit from my diet for a few years while gleefully demolishing fake protein crisps and diet coke.
Can you relate?
Perhaps rationally you struggle with the idea that fruit will make you fat. However the whole sugar thing can be confusing.
Possibly it seems improbable that although the biggest, strongest animals on earth – elephants, hippos, gorillas – are herbivores, maybe humans have some crazy fussy / advanced digestive system and to operative optimally we need some crazy fussy / advanced (confusing!) food combination?
Today I’m addressing one of the myths about living a healthy vegan lifestyle that I genuinely thought would by now have been well and truly exploded.
It’s the Myth Of Complementary Protein.
This myth was debunked by the scientific nutrition community decades ago and yet annoyingly it still persists.
In fairness I guess this is slightly less frustrating than the still too frequently blurted out: “Where do you get your protein?”
It never fails to amaze me how concerned non-health professionals suddenly are about someone’s protein levels once they hear that someone is vegan.
Let’s start with an example of the Myth Of Complementary Protein. It’ll go something like this:
“I’ve read that plant foods don’t have all the essential amino acids humans need to be healthy so you need to either eat animal products or combine certain plant foods with others to get complete proteins.”
So far as the history of the Myth Of Complementary Protein it almost certainly didn’t start with any malicious intent unlike the Soy Is Unhealthy Myth I might add.
[side note] In show ‘518: To Eat SOY Or Not To Eat Soy?’ I share how after digging deeper I learnt most anti soy scaremongering is traceable back to a single US fringe group called the Weston A Price Foundation (WAPF).
The Weston A. Price Foundation claims that saturated animal fat is essential for good health (and here I quote from their own website) “humans achieve perfect physical form and perfect health generation after generation only when they consume nutrient-dense whole foods and the vital fat-soluble activators found exclusively in animal fats.”
In direct conflict with the findings of the World Health Organisation and both the American and British Dietetic Association, WAPF also claim that animal fat intake and high cholesterol levels have no link with heart disease or cancer.
Back to the Myth Of Complementary Protein, it was inadvertently promoted and popularised by Frances Moore Lappé in her 1971 book, Diet for a Small Planet. The author stated that “plant foods are deficient in some of the essential amino acids, so in order to be a healthy vegetarian, you needed to eat a combination of certain plant foods at the same time in order to get all of the essential amino acids in the right amounts.”
Frances was a sociologist looking to end world hunger. Not a doctor, scientist or nutritionalist.
She correctly noted that the process of converting plant protein into animal protein was incredibly wasteful and that by instead directly consuming plant protein we could end world hunger. In the 10th anniversary edition of her book (1981) and again in subsequent editions Frances retracted her statement about the need for complementary protein and revealed that in trying to end one myth, that world hunger is inevitable she regrettably perpetuated another myth, about the need for complementary protein.
She unequivocally agrees with modern researchers that any single whole plant food or any combination of whole plant foods if eaten as your sole source of calories in a day would provide all the essential amino acids humans need. Not just the minimum requirements either, as long as you’re eating enough calories you’re getting more than enough essential amino acids.
To be clear:
If you eat JUST broccoli or JUST beans in a day, you’ll get enough protein.
Or to quote the wise words of Dr Michael Greger and his amazing resource nutritionfacts.org: “Protein contains essential amino acids, meaning our bodies can’t make them; and so, they are essential to get from our diet. But other animals don’t make them either. All essential amino acids originate from plants (and microbes), and all plant proteins have all essential amino acids.”
If you’re still unsure so far as protein quality and that myth that animal protein is of a higher quality then plant protein?
Dr Greger debunks this too in his article and video on The Protein Combining Myth. In short the idea that plant protein was inferior came from studies on rats over a century ago. Rat babies didn’t grow as well when fed plant protein instead of rat milk. But wait! They also didn’t as well when fed human breast milk. Because they are rats and rat milk has 10 times the amount of protein as human milk because rat babies grow 10 times as fast as humans.
One ridiculous study latched onto with volition to peddle confusion and propagate the myth that humans must gorge ourselves on the flesh on animals 3 times a day.
Having said all that, I’m still a huge fan of plant based protein and although I don’t track my macros I have done the numbers out of curiosity and I tend to hit at least 100 grams of protein a day. Here’s why,
5 Reasons To Eat More Plant Based Protein:
- Protein is satisfying. Another common myth about vegan food is: “You’ll always be hungry.” That’s only true if you swap (for example) steak for spinach. It’s one high caloric density food replaced with one super low caloric density food. It’s not the fact that your meal is vegan that leaves you hungry, it’s the fact that it’s too light-weight! Adding, lentils, beans, nuts, seeds or soy is a simple, nutritious way to make your vegan meals more satisfying.
- Protein has the highest thermic effect. That’s the amount of energy it takes to metabolize your food. Protein is the highest at up to 30%, fibrous veg are next and processed food / sugar is the lowest at as little as 3%. The idea is to consume high value whole foods that your body works hard to metabolize and wherever possible avoid low value processed crap-o-la that your body easily turns to fat.
- Plant based proteins tend to be super rich in valuable micro-nutrients and fibre. This is in stark contrast to many animal proteins I might add. Sure flesh has protein, iron, B!2 however that’s it for the good stuff. There’s NO fibre. Plus, there’s saturated fat, cholesterol, potential hormones, antibiotics and of course immeasurable cruelty.
- Plant based proteins are a better choice than processed crap-o-la! You’ve got to eat something right? When you take into account the lower caloric density of many vegan foods and the (I think) joyful side effect of a plant based lifestyle that you’ll likely need to eat larger meals, well you want to be filling up your huge plate with whole foods rather than processed foods.
- Whole food plant based proteins are super cost effective especially when purchased on mass. Do you know what’s cheap and chocka full of protein? Beans. Legumes. Tofu. Sure, the processed vegan meat / fish / dairy substitutes are not so cheap however: A) they will only come down in price as demand increase and B) a higher price for now is not such a bad thing as it encourages us to eat them on a less frequent basis as we priorities healthier whole foods.
Bonus, #6 Reason To Eat More Plant Based Protein: You can tell those pesky carnivores you easily and deliciously get over 100 grams of #plantstrong protein a day. Ok, that’s not such a valid reason however sometimes I get over the un-solicited food advice from un-qualified individuals.
I saw the best meme on Insta addressing this yesterday. It was posted by a vegan body builder I follow called @conscious_muscle.
“How can you tell if someone is vegan?
Don’t worry, when you offer them meat they will say “non thanks”, then you can ask them a bunch of questions about it which they will answer politely, then you can get upset about it for no reason.”
If you’d like to up your #plantstrong protein intake simply because it’s high value, cost effective, satisfying and delicious here are a few quick strategies:
One: The Scatter #plantstrong Protein Solution.
Top your salads, stir-fries, curries, nachos, soups, roast veg and stews with: a tablespoon or two of hemp or pumpkin seeds. 50 grams of roasted chickpeas or edamame. A scattering of your fav nuts or the ever versatile, nutritional yeast.
Two: The Stir Through #plantstrong Protein Solution.
Stir a can of four bean mix through your weekly curry mass cook up. Protein pimp your tabouli by stirring through hemp, pumpkin seeds and nutritional yeast. (Yes, these are likely my 3 Go2’s however find what you love most!). Make your oats or chia breakfast bowls even more substantial with a stir through dollop of nut butter or tahini.
One: The Blend #plantstrong Protein Solution.
Blend a few tablespoons of hemp seeds into your hummus or other fav dip. Protein pimp your smoothie with nuts or nut butter, chia seeds, spirulina and even white beans. Sneak some of your fav plant based protein powder (I love Prana Himalayan salted caramel) into banana nice cream, brownies, power balls or any sweet treat.
So much plant based protein rich deliciousness right? To get actionable today, I’d love to hear from you! Is there a persistent myth about living a healthy vegan lifestyle that you’d like me to cover in an upcoming show? Please let me know via strongbodygreenplanet on Insta or Facebook or even via good old email: firstname.lastname@example.org.
That’s it for today in Healthification.
If you’ve enjoyed this show and gotten value out of it would you consider sharing it with someone close to you? I’ve been doing some work to improve distribution / visibility of the show so it’s now available across iTunes, Stitcher, Spotify and hopefully other platforms too. However a recommendation from you to someone who you think would find value in the show would truly be most awesome!
The Healthification podcast is proudly bought to you by my FREE ‘Easy Vegan’ plan. It took me 25 years to transition from a meat eater to a happy, healthy Vegan! You can do it in just 3 days with my simplified ‘easy vegan’ plan! Get the fit, strong, and healthy plant based body you deserve… while avoiding ALL the mistakes I made along the way!
Till next time, remember Creating a body and life you love is Freedom. (If this ex-carb queen, non genetically gifted, naturally uncoordinated vegan chick can do it – so can YOU!!!)
If you liked “The Myth Of Complementary Protein” you’ll also like: The Problems Of A Dieting Mind
If you’re yet to share the Healthification love – just click here to zip over to iTunes and leave an honest rating and review. It’d help me out big time. With gratitude, Kate.